Dark Chocolate

Brookside

Brookside Dark Chocolate Acai & Blueberry

Poor Very High confidence

Why Poor

  1. Triggers Poor tier via triggered_if_any conditions: no cacao percentage listed (hard_disqualifier), alkali-processed cocoa as primary cocoa ingredient (Dutch processing without transparency), compound coating structure instead of traditional chocolate. These are automatic Poor tier triggers per category thresholds.

  2. Contains multiple red_flag ingredients that disqualify from all higher tiers: corn syrup (artificial sweetener alternative), maltodextrin (filler), canola oil (vegetable fat beyond cocoa butter), excessive sugar with sugar listed twice, ingredient count of 23+ vastly exceeds 8-ingredient maximum for even Below Average tier.

  3. Lacks all requirements for Above_average or higher tiers: no disclosed cacao percentage means cannot meet 45% minimum for Below Average tier, no chocolate liquor specifically listed, no ethical certifications (Fair Trade/Direct Trade/Organic), no sourcing transparency, ultra-processed formulation with fruit centers and glaze coating represents compound confectionery not dark chocolate.

Score breakdown

Ingredient Integrity poor - contains multiple category red_flags: corn syrup (high fructose alternative), maltodextrin (filler), cocoa processed with alkali without proper disclosure preference, milk fat in dark chocolate, excessive sugar content with sugar listed twice, no cacao percentage disclosed which is a hard_disqualifier, ingredient count exceeds category maximum of 8 with 23+ ingredients, contains compound product structure rather than traditional dark chocolate
Processing Level highly processed - Dutch processing with alkali, compound chocolate production with fruit centers, resinous glaze application, multiple emulsifiers and stabilizers, deionized juice processing, ultra-processing with fillers and coatings, does not follow traditional bean-to-bar chocolate making
Evidence & Transparency very poor - no cacao origin disclosed, no cacao percentage stated (hard_disqualifier), no information on cocoa sourcing practices, no fair trade or direct trade verification, no transparency on supplier relationships, no child labor or deforestation policies disclosed, mainstream mass-market production with no traceability
Product Quality This is a heavily processed compound chocolate product that fails fundamental dark chocolate category standards. With no disclosed cacao percentage (a hard disqualifier), alkali-processed cocoa, corn syrup, maltodextrin, 23+ ingredients versus the 8-ingredient maximum, milk fat diluting dark chocolate purity, and canola oil as an additional non-cocoa fat, this product represents ultra-processed confectionery rather than quality dark chocolate. The resinous glaze coating and compound fruit-center structure further distance it from traditional chocolate making.
Full details

Ingredients

DARK CHOCOLATE (SUGAR; CHOCOLATE; COCOA BUTTER; MILK FAT; COCOA PROCESSED WITH ALKALI; SOY LECITHIN; MILK; SALT; NATURAL VANILLA FLAVOR); SUGAR; CORN SYRUP; FRUIT JUICE CONCENTRATE (POMEGRANATE; APPLE; RASPBERRY; BLUEBERRY; CRANBERRY; LEMON JUICE CONCENTRATES); MALTODEXTRIN; DEIONIZED APPLE JUICE CONCENTRATE; NATURAL FLAVORS; PECTIN; MALIC ACID; CANOLA OIL; ACAI PUREE CONCENTRATE; SODIUM BICARBONATE; ASCORBIC ACID; SODIUM CITRATE; RESINOUS GLAZE; CITRIC ACID

Certifications

KosherGluten Free

Sourcing

Manufactured by Hershey (parent company of Brookside brand). Product contains dark chocolate with fruit juice concentrates from pomegranate, apple, raspberry, blueberry, cranberry, and lemon, plus acai puree concentrate. Mainstream positioned product with specialty flavor profile combining chocolate and fruit flavors.

Transparency notes

Full ingredient disclosure available on retailer pages. Kosher and Gluten Free certifications clearly stated. Hershey/Brookside brand ownership documented. Country of origin not specified in available sources. No organic or non-GMO certifications found.

Origin Not specified in available sources
Last verified May 2026